When you’re in the market for a heavy-duty diesel truck, the biggest debate often comes down to this: Do you save money upfront on an older, high-mileage truck, or do you spend more for a newer, low-mileage model with peace of mind?
Today, we are putting that debate to the test. We have a 100,000-mile contender versus a 10,000-mile challenger. We’re going to break down exactly what you get—and what you don't get—with each. We’ll cover price points, monthly payments, warranty coverage, and ultimately help you decide where your money is best spent.
Let’s look at the tale of the tape between a 2019 GMC Sierra 2500 Denali (118,000 miles) and a 2024 GMC Sierra 2500 Denali (10,000 miles).
The Veteran: 2019 GMC Sierra 2500 Denali (118k Miles)
This 2019 Denali is a prime example of a well-kept, high-mileage truck. It has "the look"—lifted, aftermarket wheels, tires, and flares. It’s in exceptional condition for having 118,000 miles on the odometer, having passed a rigorous shop inspection.
The Specs & Features:
-
Engine: Duramax Diesel with Allison Transmission (~450 hp / 910 lb-ft torque).
-
Towing: Max tow of approximately 15,400 lbs.
-
The Extras: Buying used often means getting free upgrades. This truck includes a painted-to-match cap with a gun holder, a bed mat, and expensive wheels/tires—easily $7,000-$9,000 in added value you don't have to pay for.
-
Interior: Standard 2019 Denali luxury with heated/cooled seats, heated steering wheel, Bose sound, and adaptive cruise control. A key feature this year has that newer ones don't is adjustable gas and brake pedals.
-
The Cons: The technology is dated (no wireless Apple CarPlay), the rear seat space is significantly tighter than newer models (especially for car seats), and it lacks the modern Multi-Pro tailgate.
The Financial Reality & The Risk This is where the rubber meets the road.
-
Price Point: ~$46,900
-
The Payment: With $5,000 down, 75 months at a 7.5% interest rate, you are looking at roughly $765 a month.
The Dealbreaker: At 118,000 miles, this truck has no factory warranty left. You are buying a gamble. If the engine or transmission goes, that cost is entirely on you. Adding an aftermarket bumper-to-bumper warranty at this mileage is very expensive (think $3,500+ for two years of coverage).
The Challenger: 2024 GMC Sierra 2500 Denali (10k Miles)
This 2024 model is practically brand new. It represents the massive redesign GMC implemented, bringing more power, better tech, and more space.
The Upgrades & Specs:
-
More Power: The updated Duramax pushes ~470 hp and a massive 975 lb-ft of torque. You can feel the difference.
-
Massive Towing Increase: Max tow jumps to 20,000 lbs—that's 4,600 lbs more capability than the 2019.
-
Exterior Improvements: Brighter dual LED headlights, power-extending and folding tow mirrors, passive keyless entry, power running boards, and the versatile Multi-Pro tailgate.
-
Interior & Tech Overhaul: A complete redesign features a massive touchscreen, wireless Apple CarPlay/Android Auto, a digital dash, and significantly more rear-seat legroom with rear heated seats and vents.
The Financial Reality & The Peace of Mind The sticker price is higher, and interest rates might be slightly better because it's newer.
-
Price Point: ~$72,000
-
The Payment: With the same structure—$5,000 down, 75 months, at roughly 6.5%—the payment is about $1,200 a month.
The Game Changer: This truck still has almost its entire full factory bumper-to-bumper and powertrain warranty remaining. For the next few years, if something breaks, it’s GM’s problem, not yours.
The Verdict: Is the $440 Difference Worth It?
Here is the final breakdown:
-
2019 (118k miles): $765/month. No warranty.
-
2024 (10k miles): $1,200/month. Full warranty.
The difference is roughly $440 per month.
For that extra $440, you get a truck with vastly superior towing capacity, more horsepower, modern technology, a much larger cabin, and, most importantly, complete peace of mind with a factory warranty.
If you are a gambling person and want the lower payment, the 2019 is a nice truck. But if you don't want to worry about a $10,000 repair bill looming over your head, the 2024 is hands-down the better value proposition, despite the higher monthly cost.
Watch the full comparison video below to see these trucks side-by-side and hear the complete breakdown.